Bank Efficiency in Risk and Uncertainty: A Network Data Envelopment Analysis Approach

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Iranian Higher Institute of Banking Education

Abstract
Evaluating bank efficiency in high-risk and uncertain environments requires analytical frameworks that can simultaneously account for the internal structure of banking operations and environmental fluctuations. This study proposes an integrated empirical framework for assessing the efficiency of listed and over-the-counter banks in Iran by combining deterministic network data envelopment analysis (NDEA) with its fuzzy extension. Using data covering the period 2018–2023, the efficiency of 16 Iranian listed and OTC banks was estimated through deterministic efficiency scores, as well as the lower bound, upper bound, and mean values of fuzzy efficiency. The results reveal a statistically meaningful gap between deterministic and fuzzy efficiency measures, indicating persistent structural and institutional inefficiencies. These inefficiencies are primarily driven by weak corporate governance, low-quality decision-making, and ineffective risk management, while environmental volatility plays an amplifying role. Substantial heterogeneity in bank efficiency was observed, largely concentrated in key stages of the financial intermediation process. The findings highlight the necessity of institutional reforms and the redesign of supervisory mechanisms to enhance banks’ resilience and performance under conditions of uncertainty

Keywords